As of August 2020, AMEE are using a new contact database. If you are logging in for the first time, please note that your login details have been refreshed and your email address is now your username. Please select 'Forgotten Password' the first time you try and login

BP10 - Peer review: keeping horses in the stable or encouraging them to bolt?

Date:  Tuesday 8 September
Time:  0915-1015 and 1645-1745
Stream: 2
Theme: Education Management

Moderator: Tim Dornan, UK

Presenters:
Richard Hays, AMEE MedEdPublish, Australia
Martin Delahunty, Inspiring STEM Consulting, UK
Rebecca Lawrence, F1000, UK

Summary:
Pre-publication peer review is currently the ‘gold standard’ of academic rigour. It results, though, in good articles being rejected or altered beyond recognition. Peer review, though, has been authoritatively described as so unreliable that, if it were a drug, it would not be allowed on the market. This symposium will consider whether peer review is the best means of advancing the field or conserves the status quo. It will present post-publication peer review as an alternative, ask whether this could be a more democratic route to scholarly excellence, and whether wastage of good work and disillusionment of authors could become a thing of the past.

Twitter_001 facebook_001 Google_Plus_001 Linkedin_001 YouTube_001